President Donald Trump has threatened to double tariffs on Mexican goods unless Mexico stops a migrant caravan moving north from Chiapas, adding a new pressure point to a relationship already strained by stalled trade talks, an unresolved USMCA review and a dispute over CIA activity in Mexico.

President Claudia Sheinbaum answered the same day by rejecting force against migrants and pointing to the record: “Not a single migrant caravan has reached the north” since January 2025.

Tariff Threat

In an early-morning Truth Social post on Thursday, November 12, Trump wrote:

“MEXICO MUST STOP THEM, NOW, and if they do not do so, the Tariffs on Mexico will be IMMEDIATELY DOUBLED.”

The post set no deadline and did not say which tariffs would rise. The caravan began walking north from Tapachula on Tuesday, November 10.

Size estimates vary widely: Reuters said over 1,000, a Chiapas source said about 1,500, EFE said about 2,000, and AP reported about 600 migrants had largely dispersed. U.S. officials reinforced the message.

U.S. Border czar Tom Homan said Mexico “needs to step up” and put troops on its borders, while Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said the caravan “will NOT be allowed to enter our country.”

President Trump repeated the warning to reporters on Monday before leaving for Asia, saying that if Mexico does not stop the migrants, “we’re going to put heavy tariffs on Mexico.”

Sheinbaum Responds

Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum ruled out force against the approaching migrants. She said Mexico will use persuasion, convince migrants that reaching the U.S. is very difficult, and seek safe returns to home countries, though migrants may stay in Mexico under certain conditions.

The pattern is not new. The group is now the third caravan since September; the first two broke up in Chiapas, and their members received temporary permits to stay in Mexico. Mexican authorities also stopped a separate group of about 100 on Tuesday and detained about 40.

President Donald Trump in the Oval Office, White House, Washington, D.C. in January 2025. Credit: Reuters

The legal footing for doubling duties is unclear. The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 on February 20 that the emergency-powers tariffs were unlawful because taxing power belongs to Congress, and the administration said it would use other trade statutes, which have tighter limits on how fast and how far tariffs can rise.

The duties most exposed are those on Mexican steel, aluminum and vehicles, imposed last year under Section 232, which Mexico is negotiating to reduce. Current rates are 10% on Mexican goods that don’t qualify under USMCA, 25% on medium- and heavy-duty trucks, and 50% on steel and aluminum, although other outlets report different figures, so the baseline for any “doubling” is unsettled.

The stakes are large: Mexico is the largest U.S. trading partner, with about $96 billion in two-way trade in September alone.

Strained Relations?

The caravan threat lands on top of other open areas of complication between the two North American partners. The Trump administration decided in July not to renew USMCA for 16 years, with U.S. concerns including Mexico’s trade relationship with China. Mexico is seeking lower duties on steel, aluminum and vehicles, and steel and aluminum talks have stalled.

The New York Times reported that a former Chihuahua special prosecutor, Guillermo Zuany Portillo, helped the CIA operate in Mexico in exchange for a U.S. visa, and Sheinbaum said the CIA’s role in an April drug lab raid violated the National Security Law. She called the alleged collaboration “very significant, even for the bilateral relationship,” while saying she expects no friction because the matter has been discussed with the U.S. government.

China adds another layer. Sheinbaum travels to Shenzhen on November 17–19 for the APEC forum, where she will pitch Plan México to investors and meet Xi Jinping. She says the trip should not complicate negotiations with Washington, and she will not meet Trump there; she said she will “probably” meet him at the G20 summit in December, where the tariff and USMCA issues are likely to be on the table.

Taken together, the reporting points to a familiar dynamic rather than a break. Washington applies public pressure tied to migration, Mexico responds by pointing to enforcement results while avoiding confrontation, and the larger questions about trade and security stay unresolved.

Sheinbaum has so far avoided retaliation and force, which keeps channels open ahead of the G20. The risk for Mexico is that a threat with no stated deadline or legal mechanism keeps uncertainty hanging over exporters and investors during negotiations, and gives Washington leverage on files that have little to do with migration.